How powerful a telescope is needed to see the things left behind at the Apollo Moon landing sites from here on earth? There are several parts to the answer. If you want to skip the details, here is the result.
A telescope of this size is about 100 times larger than any we have built. It is easier to send a much smaller telescope closer to the Moon as we have with the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter and perhaps even easier to return in person...
Human eyes can only detect objects that are about 1 arc minute (1/60 of a degree in size). To calculate the size of the details we need to see, we will solve the triangle defined by our eye, the distance to the Moon, and the distance we want to resolve. We will use units of Radians for our angles, because this makes the calculation simpler.
Lets assume that we would like to see the Apollo left behinds with details of about 10 cm (about 4 inches or 0.1 meters). The Moon is about 400,000 km away (4x10^8 meters). We have two sides of a right triangle and can solve it for the angle that our eye must see. A handy simplification is the small angle approximation:
Using this equation, the angle that we must see is:
0.1/4x10^8 = 2.5x10^(-10) radians
We must magnify this tiny angle to be large enough for our eye to see, 1 arc minute ( 1/(60 * 57.3) = 0.0003 R)
magnification = 0.0003 / 2.5x10^(-10) = 1.2x10^6 power
Our telescope must have a magnification of at least 1.2 million times! We can calculate the focal length of our telescope using a magnification equation and our eyepiece focal length. About 4mm is the shortest eyepiece that we can practically use in a telescope.
Using this formula our telescope focal length must be:
fo = fe * magnification = 4x10^(-3) * 1.2x10^6 = 4.8x10^3 = 4.8 km (3 miles)
In addition to magnifying power, we need to consider the diffraction limited resolution of this telescope. The wave nature of light causes it to be diffracted when it passes through the aperture that defines the telescopes objective size. This puts a practical limit on the magnification of a telescope with a given size aperture before the image becomes too blurry. The diameter of the telescope's objective (lens or mirror) is determined by this diffraction limit.
The physics of diffraction are well understood theoretically and empirically. Dawes' limit is one often used measure of diffraction limited resolution:
R=116/D with Resolution in arc sec, and apperture D in mm
1 arc sec =
1/(57.3 * 60 * 60) Radians = 1/206280 R = 4.85x10^(-6) R
R =
5.6x10^(-4)/D with D in mm and R in radians
D = 5.6x10^(-7)/R with D in
m and R in radians
Substituting our required resolution of 2.5x10^(-10) radians
D =
5.6x10^(-7)/2.5x10^(-10) = 2240 m = 2.24 km (1.4 miles)
Turbulence in the air limits the detail that we can see to about 1 arc second. This will certainly spoil our view of the Apollo sites. The telescope needs to be above the air in low earth orbit to give us a clear view.
Content created: 2018-02-10
Submit comments or questions about this page.
By submitting a comment, you agree that: it may be included here in whole or part, attributed to you, and its content is subject to the site wide Creative Commons licensing.
Flaming Star Nebula dark sky vrs city sky face-off
Christmas Tree Cluster and Cone Nebula with more exposure
Christmas Tree Cluster with the Cone Nebula
Horsehead Nebula Face-Off Bortle 2 vrs Bortle 7
California Nebula Face-Off Bortle 2 vrs Bortle 7
Western Veil Nebula from Marfa
Trifid and Lagoon Nebulae Drizzle Stacked
North America and Penguin Nebulae Drizzle Stacked
Return to Coconino Andromeda, M31
Revisiting the Willow House Rosette
Corazón Incendida, the Heart Nebula
Elephant Trunk with the Garnet Star
Balanced HO North America & Pelican Nebulae
The Lagoon & Trifid Nebulas from Marfa
Western Veil Nebula from Marfa
The Great Winter Solstice Conjunction of Jupiter and Saturn
Two days to the Great Jupiter Saturn Conjunction
Worlds Apart, the Jupiter Saturn Conjunction
Raspberry Pi HQ camera first light
Waxing Crescent Moon with earthshine and stars
Vixen Porta II mount adapter or aluminum disk with holes #2
The 2019 ACEAP Expedition to Chile
Universe of Stories: Getting Started in Astronomy
View an Apollo flag on the Moon from Earth?
Apollo 50th is my 24th Flickr Explore Selection
Shooting the video stars - Moon and Jupiter
Ready for a change in perspective
Jupiter and the Galilean Moons through a camera lens
2022 the Solar System in one view
As hard to see as a doughnut on the Moon
Santa Inez miners church Terlingua
Waning gibbous Moon early Christmas Eve
Christmas eve on the eastern limb of the Moon
Mars at 23.3 arc sec with Syrtis Major
BadAstroPhotos Web Site Analytics
Saturn with Pixinsight workflow
Mars Update from Mauri Rosenthal
Waxing Gibbous Moon Terlingua Texas
Io Transit of Jupiter with the Great Red Spot
Not so bad Astro after 2 years
Eyes of the Llama from Urubamba
Moon and Venus over Cusco's El Monasterio
Tiangong-1 Space Station reentry tracking
Apollo - 50 years of human footprints on the Moon, complete!
Waxing Crescent Moon after Astrophotography Meetup
The Great American Eclipse from Above and Below
A million astro photo views on Flickr
Ansel Adams: Moonrise, Hernandez, New Mexico
December Solstice Crescent Moon with Earthshine
January 31 Blue Moon Lunar Eclipse
The Total Solar Eclipse in half a minute
2017 Solar Eclipse from a million miles away
Longhorn Eclipse from a Wyoming Hilltop
Fibs, damn lies, telescopes, and astrophotography
Full Moon before Total Solar Eclipse 2017
Longhorn Crescent Moon from Austin
The Crescent Moon with Jupiter and moons
Eye of the storm 2 - Juno & Jupiter's Great Red Spot
Eye of the storm - Juno & Jupiter's Great Red Spot
A million miles from earth, the Moon and earth east and west
Saturn with Titan, Dione, Tethys, & Rhea
Animated transit of Jupiter by Io
Solar Eclipse 2017 Highway Traffic Map
Mid-South Star Gaze + Questar Meet
Sweet Home Alabama Transit of Jupiter by Io
Update on AutoStakkert on macOS
Diffraction is not the limit for digital images
Teasing life into planetary images
Moon camera comparison: DSLR & planetary cameras
Waning Crescent Moon with Earthshine
1st day of Spring last quarter Moon
Lewis Morris Rutherfurd's Moon
Super Moonrise over Lady Bird Lake
360 Tower pierces the Super Moon
Lisbeth's Birthday Crescent Moon
The Moon and Mars from the Astro Café
Silent and Mechanical Shutter Comparison
Austin's Solar Sidewalk Sun-Day
Another Longhorn Moon over Austin
Jupiter and Venus do a father-daughter dance
Sunset with Mercury, Jupiter, and Venus
Mercury, Jupiter & Venus after sunset
3 months, 92 nations, 3750 visitors, 100,000+ images served
Upcoming Conjunction of Jupiter & Venus
The Perseid Meteor Shower with the Andromeda Galaxy
Waxing crescent Moon from UHD Video
NWS Interactive Digital Forecast Map
M7 the Ptolemy Cluster preview
Five Planets in the Sky at Dusk
Lucky Fat Waning Crescent Moon
Two months, 80 nations, and an embarrassing bug
Saturn with 5 moons: Titan, Rhea, Enceladus, Tethys, & Dione
The nearly full Moon and Saturn with a short tube refractor